Chapter 5 - An Unexpected Truce in the Kitchen
Mateo did not raise his voice, nor did he reach for a phone to call security. He simply stepped further into the cramped archive room, closing the heavy mahogany door behind him with a soft thud that reverberated through the stone walls. His chest tattoos peeked slightly above the open collar of his black button-down shirt as he crossed his arms, leaning his shoulder against a towering bookshelf filled with leather-bound ledgers. His dark eyes locked onto mine, flickering from my tense face down to the open 1954 ledger resting on the oak desk.
"You're remarkably difficult to keep away, Tessa," Mateo said, his voice low and even, devoid of the sharp command he had used earlier in the dining room. "My grandfather told you to stay home. He didn't mean it as a suggestion."
"I needed to know why," I replied, my voice holding steady despite the adrenaline spiking through my veins. I pressed my palm flat against the open ledger page, shielding the handwritten entry with my body. "Your grandfather looked at me like I was a ghost tonight. He asked about my great-grandmother's name. You both reacted like I dropped a bomb on that white-clothed table. I have a right to know what happened between our families seventy years ago."
Mateo stared at me for a long, agonizing moment, the silence in the vault thick with unspoken history. Slowly, he uncrossed his arms and walked over to the desk, stopping just inches away. He didn't try to pull my hand away from the book. Instead, he reached into his inner suit pocket and withdrew a small, worn leather wallet. From it, he slid a folded piece of heavy stock photograph paper across the wooden surface toward me.
I glanced down, hesitant, then pulled the photograph closer. It showed a young woman with the same auburn-red hair as mine, sitting on a bench in a public park, laughing up at a young man who looked unmistakably like a younger Salvatore Vitiello. But written in faded ink across the bottom margin were the words: *Rosa and Salvatore, Chicago, 1953*.
"My grandfather built this entire empire on ambition," Mateo murmured, his gaze dropping to the photograph as well. "He left a lot of collateral damage in his wake when he consolidated power in the fifties. Most people he pushed aside stayed quiet because they were afraid or because they took his hush money. But your great-grandmother didn't take the money. She took a secret instead."
"What secret?" I asked, my breath catching in my throat.
"That's what my grandfather has spent his entire life trying to bury," Mateo said, looking back up into my eyes. "And by showing up in that maid uniform speaking his mother's childhood dialect, you just dug it back up. If Salvatore finds you in these archives, he won't just fire you. He'll make sure you vanish from this city entirely."
May you like
"Then why aren't you calling security right now?" I challenged, my chin lifting defensively. "Why are you standing here talking to me?"
Mateo let out a quiet, humorless breath, shaking his head slightly. "Because I'm tired of cleaning up my family's sins, Tessa. And because for the first time in my life, I want to know the truth as badly as you do. Help me put the pieces together, and I'll make sure you walk out of here with more than just a stolen ledger page."
